Hover a note to see the line it points at. Click a note (or a highlighted phrase) to pin it and open the why, the recommendation, a suggested sentence, and the readers' own words.
If you had pulled up my calendar back then, you would not have called me a homebody. Every square inch of my calendar was full. Small group on Tuesdays, a Wednesday thing at church I can’t even remember the name of now, a happy hour with friends, a baby shower for someone I’d met twice, a brunch I said yes to before I checked whether I had a brunch that day already (I did). I was an overcommitter with too many friends and a yes problem, and if you’d told me I was in a rut I would have laughed at you from the back of someone’s Uber on my way to the third thing of the night.
But if you’d looked a little closer at that calendar, you’d have noticed every single square was the same color. Same church. Same small group. Same friends of friends of friends who also went to that church, at the same three brunch spots everyone from that church went to, which meant every Sunday I was eating eggs with people I’d already hugged in the church lobby an hour before. I wasn’t doing the same thing every week. I was doing a hundred things with the same world every week.
It got so easy. My church community was lovely and full and knew my name and my story, and that is exactly why I never left it. When you’ve got a warm place to go every night of the week, you don’t notice that every night of the week is the same place.
And here’s the part that still makes me laugh. I lived in New York City. Then Los Angeles. Two of the most crowded, something-new-on-every-block cities on the planet, and I had managed to turn both of them into a church lobby.
So when I said the sentence I now hear from almost every single person I coach, I meant it with my whole heart. “I just don’t know where to meet godly people.”
Maybe you’ve said it too. Maybe you said it in the car after church, pulling out of the parking lot , because the singles in that building barely have graduated from college. Maybe you said it on a Friday night with your hair up in a claw clip, after the group chat spent all afternoon “making plans” that turned into the same four friends on the same couch, again, and you love those people, and you still went to bed feeling sad about it. Maybe you’ve said it to your phone, face-down on the nightstand, with an app on it you’ve already deleted twice. It felt true when you said it…because it’s partly true. The truth is, people you’re hoping to meet are not showing up in your daily life.
That sentence has a problem hiding inside it, though, and it took me an embarrassing number of years to find it. Godly people were everywhere. They just weren’t in my church (which, to be fair, was a great church).
The first time I did anything about it, Heart of Dating wasn’t even a glimmer of an idea. I was living in New York, and something was driving me a little crazy. There were great guys and great girls at my church, and at the church in the neighborhood next door, and at the one my roommate went to in Soho. And not one of them had ever met each other. I realized then that every church was its own little island of singles, and every island was convinced it was the last one on earth.
So a few of us from a few of those churches got together one night and sent an email. We had no platform and no following. What we had was a list of everybody we could think of, and an email that basically said, we’re hosting a rooftop soirée for eligible singles from churches around the city, come meet some people you’d never otherwise cross paths with. I had never done anything like this before. I hit send and then found myself terrified that eleven people would show up and I’d have to make small talk with all of them for three hours.
But the craziest thing happened. A little over a hundred came.
I’ve since heard a couple of marriages trace back to that rooftop, and I would love to take the credit for those (I’m taking a bit of it). But I didn’t do anything magical that night. The room I wanted didn’t exist, so I found a rooftop, and a hundred strangers showed up on it.
When a client tells me there’s just no one out there, I ask them two questions. The first is, are you actively putting yourself out there? And I don’t mean are you “open to it,” which is what we all say, I mean actually looking, the way you look for your keys when you’re already late.
The second question is the one that changed everything for me, and it’s one word. Where? My answer was a rooftop in Brooklyn with a folding table of Trader Joe’s snacks and cheap wine and a lot of nervous people pretending they weren’t there to meet their spouse. Yours probably won’t be a rooftop, but we have to figure out something.
But first I have to be a little annoying about the first question, because almost nobody answers it honestly.
If I had a dollar for every time a client said that sentence to me in our first call, I could have more than paid for that very first rooftop soiree. And I get it, because it’s a lovely sentence that sounds exactly like someone with a ton of faith has, and about half the time it’s the spiritual version of sitting on the couch with the TV on and the phone charging across the room so you won’t be tempted to check it.
Trust me, I said it too. I said it with a highlighter in my hand and a Bible app streak going, and I said it while turning down a dinner where I knew there’d be new people, and I called that trusting God when really I was just tired.
Proverbs 18:22 is the verse I didn’t often think of when single (ironic, I know). “He who finds a wife finds a good thing.” Read that again and look at the verb. Finds, the way you find a parking spot in Los Angeles, which is to say you drive around endlessly trying not to lose your mind. And before any of the women reading this breathe a sigh of relief that the verb belongs to the guys only, flip over to Proverbs 31:10. “A wife of noble character who can find?” It’s the same word, and this time it’s her they’re out looking for.
My favorite picture of this is in Genesis 24, which is the story of how Isaac got a wife, when really it’s barely about Isaac at all. Abraham sends his most trusted servant on a road trip to go find a wife for his son, and the servant is nervous. This is a man who does not want to pick wrong (relatable ha!). So he gets to the town, he stops at the well, and then he prays. He prays one of the most specific prayers in the whole Bible, basically, Lord, let the girl who offers water to me and my camels be the one. And verse 15 is where it gets me every time. “Before he had finished praying,” Rebekah walked up with her jar.
Some of you are tempted to say “ SEE look God brought her to him! That’s why I am waiting. But my friend, you are missing something key. You have to notice where the servant was when he prayed. He was at the well. He had loaded up the camels back home, traveled for days, and parked himself at the one spot in town where every woman would eventually walk by at the end of the day, and then he asked God to do what only God can do.
That’s the part of “waiting on God” we skip when we’re exhausted. (And we don’t skip it in secret, either. We almost always reshare our favorite IG post about it.) The servant prayed, and then he moved and put himself in proximity to where the women were!
And if you want a woman doing this, you are not counted out here my friend. Ruth met Boaz because she had to eat. She was out gleaning barley behind the harvesters, which was the welfare system of the day, and she “happened” to end up in his field, and he noticed her. That part wasn’t a strategy ,but the next part was. Naomi, who was basically the first ever dating coach, found out Boaz would be at the threshing floor that night and told Ruth exactly what to do: wash up, put on your best clothes, go down there, and don’t let him know you’re there until he’s done eating. Ruth went and followed her instructions and guess what? Nobody in that story calls her desperate for it. The words they use are “noble character,” which is the same phrase from Proverbs 31, and I don’t think that’s an accident.
I am not saying God needs your help. Rebekah was walking toward that well before the servant finished his sentence, which means she’d left her house before he even started it. But, the servant still had to be at the well to see her come, and if he’d stayed home praying the same beautiful prayer, she would have filled her jar and walked back to her father’s house, and the story would have a very different ending.
So keep the prayer. I just want you to pray somewhere other than your couch.
For most of my twenties I had a lot of guy friends, and I mean a lot, and they were some of my favorite people. By then I’d moved to Los Angeles and was running my own thing, which sounds glamorous and mostly meant working from a coffee shop until somebody texted “sunset walk?” We’d go to each other’s birthdays and each other’s church events. I’d call one of them when a client fell through and he’d let me talk it out on his drive home. And for a long time I believed, with my whole heart, that guys and girls could just be friends. In fact back then I would have argued with you about it.
But flash forward to today and my mind has completely shifted. Because I started to notice something with my guy friends, and I saw it enough times that I couldn’t pretend it was just a coincidence. Take any good guy friend of mine, the kind where you’ve spent real hours together. You’ve seen how he treats a waiter and how he handles a bad week and whether he’s the one who stays to help clean up after everybody else has left. Nine times out of ten, over time, one of us ended up liking the other. So what did I do? I dated a few of them, and I have to be honest that more than one of those guys would have been a great husband.
Which is why Tim Keller’s line is the one I’d tattoo on every single person I coach, if they’d let me. “Marriage is not basically romance garnished with friendship. It is basically friendship garnished with romance.” Read the order again. Friendship is the meal. Romance is the parsley. And what I’d stumbled into in my twenties without meaning to, was exactly that order: the friendship came first, and the feelings followed in later and sat down like they’d been invited.
Keller also told a story in a sermon that I’ve never been able to shake. A guy got married, and his best man was a woman, because she was his best friend in the world, and she stood up there next to him and handed over the rings. Keller said he had no problem with the best man being a woman at all. What bothered him was what it said about the groom. He had his best friend standing right there, holding the ring, but he was choosing to build a marriage with someone else, when he should have married the best friend.
I’ve watched so many stories like that happen. A single woman in my community has a guy friend who shows up for her, texts her first, remembers what she said last week, and when I ask her about him she gets a look on her face and says one of three things. “I don’t want to ruin the friendship.” “He’s basically my brother.” Or the one that ends the conversation, “I’m just not attracted to him.”
Sometimes that’s true, and that’s the end of it. But go back to chapter five for a second. Attraction has five parts, and the personality bucket is all about friendship. If someone already has that one, they are not starting at zero, they’re starting ahead of every stranger on a dating app. The guy you’ve already laughed with for three years has a head start you keep refusing to admit. (And no, he’s not your brother. You don’t put on mascara to see your brother.)
[JJ slot A: the guy’s version. “She’s like a sister,” and what that usually means. ~150 words.]
Every few months a study comes out about how couples meet, and every few months the same thing is true: the way most people meet now is online. Much to many singles disney, dating has superseded meeting “through friends” a long time ago.¹ Now I want you to hold that loosely, because a study is not a strategy, and because after coaching thousands of Christian singles (and dating significantly myself) I’ve watched meet their person through a plethora of ways, and almost never just one. But of all the various ways I could list out to you, there are four that seem to come to the top over and over.
Meeting through friends, which we just covered. Meeting through the things they normally do. Meeting online. And meeting in rooms full of strangers.
The things you do. I had a client a couple of years ago, Jayme, who told me on our first call that she’d been on maybe a handful of dates in three years. By the time she met her guy, she’d been on something like eighty. (Breathe, I’ll explain.) She did not become a totally different person to get that many dates, she simply changed up her strategy. She went to a conference alone, she got on a few new dating apps, and she talked to a man in an airport. Eighty dates sounds like an actual horror movie if you’re picturing eighty heartbreaks. It was eighty casual hangouts with eighty people she got to know a little, most of whom she wished well and never saw again, and one of whom she married. Nothing about Jayme’s odds changed except the number of people she met.
Which is the part about hobbies that nobody wants to admit. It’s not that pickleball is romantic. It’s that a hobby puts you next to the same people every week with something to talk about that isn’t you, and that’s honestly the closest thing to how we all made friends in college. So pick something you’d do anyway, and then be a little sneaky about it. If you’re a woman, I have to be honest with you, the Pilates studio is lovely and fun and all, but it is ninety percent women in matching sets. So go to the driving range instead. There are approximately two women there and forty men, and every single one of those men would love to show you how to fix your swing, including the ones who can’t fix their own. If you’re a guy, the spin class, the farmers market and the volunteer crew at a women’s conference are all places where you will be statistically a novelty, which is to your benefit trust me. And for both, dog parks, run clubs, rec leagues, and any sporting event where strangers typically are friendly with one another.
Online. A few years ago, at our 2023 singles conference, a woman named Hannah stood up and said something that I have come to discover a lot of singles think. She said she’d always believed that if she downloaded a dating app, she was giving up on God’s plans for her. But then she said that now she felt like being on the app was opening avenues for God to move through to meet people she never would have before. Same woman, same Father Son and Holy Spirit, same dating app. The only thing that changed was the story she was telling herself about what going on the apps meant.
I’ve heard Hannah’s story a hundred times in a hundred mouths, and it’s a wildly holy-sounding way to avoid online dating. But you have to hear me when I say, an app is just a room. Granted, it’s a loud room with bad lighting and some people in it you’d never want to meet, which is also a description of most bars and at least one church I’ve been to. So don’t put your hope in it, but do still show up to it…just in case. That is also to say, not all apps are created equal. There are Christian apps now, and even the big ones have more believers on them than you’d think. So, since I’ve reviewed more dating profiles than I’ve eaten hot meals, let me save you some time.
Pick two apps, not six, and start on the free versions. Give it ten minutes in the morning and ten at night, and then put the phone down and live your life. Your first photo is a half-body shot of you smiling in daylight. Not a selfie, not a group shot where I have to guess which one is you, not a photo of you in sunglasses like you’re in witness protection. One photo doing something you love, one dressed up like you’ve got a wedding to go to, and at least one full-body photo, because the right person is not going to be scared of all of you.
Your bio is not a list. Nobody in the history of the internet has fallen in love with a bullet point list describing yourself. Leave the lists for your saturday errand run. Tell them about yourself in a way that seems like setting the stage for a story. Ask one question somebody could reply to, and keep it playful. Something like, overrated: brunch, underrated: breakfast for dinner, and then you’ll see who argues with you.
Then get off the app… as soon as possible. If you’re on message forty and you still don’t know what their voice sounds like, you don’t have a match, you now have a pen pal, and last I checked pen pals are for the third grade. Please know there will be disappointment, it’s the name of the game. But this is the lowest-stakes dating there is. It’s a stranger on the internet. If they stop replying after the third message, you have not been rejected, you’ve been un-replied-to by someone whose last name you didn’t know. If you have realistic expectations and a positive mindset, online dating can actually be enjoyable (gasp I know!).
Rooms full of strangers. The last way to meet people is the one a lot of people tend to skip, and it’s the one I built a rooftop for. Go to things where you don’t know anyone. The conference, the young adults night at the church across town, the wedding where you only know the bride or groom. I promise you I am not crazy! If you want to be talked to, go place solo with new people you don’t know. Every year at our singles conference I watch it happen in real time. Over 50% of people come to conference by themselves. I am always amazed at that fact, and relish in seeing the outcome of such bravery. Two people who would never have crossed paths stand in the same coffee line, and one of them says something about the coffee, and that’s it, that’s the whole origin story. Sara, who you met in chapter five, was at one of our events when the guy she’s now married to reached out to her, and if she’d stayed home that weekend she would have gone on being single and convinced herself there was nobody out there.
And here is the rule I’d staple to the front door of every one of those rooms, for the women especially. Do not go in a pack. I have watched it a hundred times. Three or more women walk in together, find a corner, form a circle, laugh at their own jokes, and then go home and say nobody talked to them. But picture it from his side. A wall of three, arms crossed, ladies where one of them clearly the bodyguard…a man would need a letter of introduction and a small act of Congress to walk up to that. That is way too intimidating to the average guy. So go alone, or go with one friend, and agree before you walk in that you’ll split up for twenty minutes. (Men, same for you. Nobody has ever flirted with a wolf pack.)
Here’s the math that matters more than any study. You don’t need more dates. You need to meet more people, so the dates you do go on have somewhere to come from. Get your numbers up, and I mean the number of people you’ve met this month, not the number you’ve kissed. One new square on the calendar, in a new color, once a week. Jamie did it for about a year and ended up at an altar. Most people won’t need eighty. Most people need about eight, and the nerve to go to the first one alone.
“I don’t want to go alone.” I spent Valentine’s Day of 2019 at Disneyland by myself. Single, no friend who could get the day off, and a decision I made at 9AM that morning that I was not going to sit in my apartment and watch other people’s romantic IG posts and cutesy dates on Instagram. So I drove down, got in line for the Cars ride, and ended up behind a guy who turned out to be a single dad on his own that day too, there for exactly the reason I was. We talked the whole line. And then we rode a couple of rides together. Nothing came of it, and that is not the point. The point is that I have never once met somebody new while standing in a tight circle of four friends I already had. When you go alone you are available to the person in front of you in a way you never are when you’re busy being half of a conversation. Some of the best dates of my life started with a dinner I ate alone, a trip I took alone, or a room I walked into with no plus-one. If going alone sounds like a punishment, go with one friend and make a deal that you’ll both talk to a stranger. If it still sounds like a punishment, go anyway. Everyone in that room is hoping somebody talks to them, and you just might be that somebody.
“It feels awkward.” Because it can be. The first run club feels like the first day of middle school, and the second one feels like the second day, and by the fourth one you’re complaining about the route with people who know your name. Awkward is what new feels like for just about any new endeavor.
“It seems desperate.” Gosh this is a tough one. Let me ask you something. If you needed a job, would you call it desperate to apply for one? Would it be desperate to go to the interview, follow up with the recruiter, or apply somewhere else when it fell through? Of course not. You’d call that normal. Putting yourself in rooms where you might meet someone is the same thing, and it only turns desperate when your heart has decided it needs this to work, when your worth is riding on whether anyone talks to you, when you’re doing math on your age in the car on the way there. We spent all of chapter three getting your worth out of other people’s hands, and this is where it pays off. Go to the thing and have hope that it goes well. But do yourself a favor and drive home totally okay even if it didn’t go as planned.
One more thing before I hand you to JJ, None of this is a hunt. The run club is not a meat market, the conference is amazon shopping, and the people in those rooms are not inventory you flip through until you find your size. Every single person there is a brother and a sister in Christ first. Some of them will become friends, great friends in fact. If the only reason you’d go to a church across town is to scan the room, stay home. Go because you’d like to meet people, treat every one of them like someone you want to leave better than you found, and for goodness sakes enjoy the process!
So here is your assignment. Open your calendar right now, the real one on your phone, and pick out a day within the next week. Put something on it that is a different color from everything else, a room where nobody knows your name yet, whether that’s the run club you keep driving past, the driving range, a young adults night at a church you’ve never been to, or the dating app profile you’ve been meaning to finish since spring. Then text one friend what you just added to your calendar, because you will do it if somebody knows and you will not if nobody doesn’t. I’d do it before you turn the page, because we both know what happens to the things we save for later.
Lone Wolf: You’ll go anywhere alone, and then stand in the corner looking busy. Your shift? Having a slot on the calendar and just showing up is good, but it’s half the battle. Try to talk to a few new people once you’re there.
Hopeless Romantic: You’re holding out for the perfect meet-cute, so online dating feels beneath your love story. Your shift? Be open to the unexpected. Every love story I know looked boring until later.
Overthinker: You research the event for a week and decide the night before it’s not the right one, again. Your shift? Buy the ticket before the research starts and let your financial commitment decide for you.
Safety Seeker: Your calendar is all color coded the same color, and it’s the coziest one in this book. Your shift? Get out of your comfort zone and change up at least 2 out of the 3 same routines that you normally do.
Wanderer: You’ve tried the run club, the pickleball, and three churches, once each. Your shift? Pick one and go back for the fourth week, because consistency is what is going to get you to find someone worthwhile.
Intentional Romantic: You know exactly who you’re looking for, and you’re very prepared for a room you haven’t walked into. Your shift? Go where the list lives, and bring a friend who’ll hold you accountable to it.
¹ Rosenfeld, Thomas & Hausen, “Disintermediating your friends,” PNAS 116(36), 2019.